"No kidding, it was a transit camp. What work?" Funny place for a transit camp. Where are the buildings for housing? Local people would see people leaving, as well as arriving. No reports of that that I know of. Do you know of some? Then we have this from Alan Heath http://www.youtube.com/...

"Of course not, have you actually read what I posted previously? Doesn't look like it." I did do so but found much of what I read repetitious, and unconvincing and so gave up. "The outbound records, which were necessarily kept, are missing. Now who would do such a thing? " How ar...

Well after about the twentieth time of being required to log in and then the third effort to make a reply , all due to thicko operator error I am sure, here goes. "You must do better than this if you think mass murder was accomplished" Except that I only suspect that mass murder took place...

I replied to this earlier but there seems to be something wrong with the software on this site. The whole lot vanished when I hit the 'preview' button. So I will reply bit by bit at my leisure.

Hannover says, "So then chim-pa, you buy the extermination at Chelmno story. And if you are trying to make the case that 150,000 Jews were not resettled, the question remains, where are the 150,000 alleged corpses at Chelmno? It always comes down to basics." Quite so. I must say I am with ...

I agree with Barrington-James' post. While it is good to keep things focussed on the holocaust (and the moderators do a good job on this), like him, I do feel this has its limitations. One oddity that results, is that by confining posts(over strictly) to this (alleged) phenomenon, you are exaggerati...

The Warden says Also, if an excavation is done on the burial site in 65 years, the remains will be there. ....and ground penetration radar would reveal any excavation. And somebody would have smelled smells and somebody would have seen smoke, and at night somebody, maybe many, would have seen fires ...

Having a look through the papers I came across this http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/this-britain/footandmouth-10th-anniversary-2235770.html in the British newspaper, the Independent.(then click on the image to get the gallery of pictures) I'd be most interested to get your reactions. This is as...

To Kingfisher Apologies kingfisher. Maybe 'dismissive' is a bit too strong. Nevertheless, a few months back there was the call to show us bones,bone ash or fragments, real forensic evidence. I thought someone would bring up the subject of this display of forensic material... but no. Strangely no-one...

I thank you for your response "proxyserver" and echo your disappointment at the lack of response and the rather dismissive comments such as "Carlo's bringing a book out about it." Maybe so, but he's taking a long time to do it. That seems to have been the response to enquiries fo...

I have gone through previous posts on this camp, seldom mentioned or quoted by holocaust doubters. In my opinion the deniers/doubters have made a good case with respect to Auschwitz, Majdanek, Belzec, Sobibor and Treblinka....yet curiously Chelmno gets left out. Yes, I know it was regarded as a mino...

"Run out of pilots, this is just made up." says Carlos Cutlass Supreme, from distant Northern California. No, once again it may not be entirely accurate, but a gentleman would be prepared to make some concession to the constraints imposed by the attempt to summarise a complex period of his...

BJ,says that 95% or whatever, of German Jews had nothing to do with Zionism.I broadly agree. I understand that as meaning that Zionism wasn't a big thing for them, and for those that were interested, that's all it was...interest. This is supported by my own anecdotal evidence which comes from German...

What a masterly summary, Barrington-James. I salute you. That's going straight in to my archives. I fully realise the problems of summary for posts on the internet, nevertheless I do think it worthwhile to mention the effect of the demand of Churchill and Roosevelt for "unconditional surrender&...

This is a most momentous publication to hit the European press, albeit in a somewhat marginal country. I note that this website concentrates on the holocaust. Anything regarded as peripheral is dismissed and my last post was dismissed, although there was some silly stuff going on at the time. So sec...