"Millions of Jews were murdered during the Holocaust
because circumcision marked them as Jews! This must
never happen again! Everyone should be circumcised!"
American Academy of Pediatrics Annual Conference
Hyatt-Regency Hotel, Chicago, April 14, 1996
[The pediatrician she spat this out to and a nurse who
heard her (both of whom asked to remain anonymous)
told me this in two separate conversations. The nurse
said there were not enough exclamations points in the
universe to convey the ferocity this woman displayed.
How common is this woman's attitude -- especially
among obstetricians, pediatricians and urologists?]
No matter what you think about the quoted above text, a clear contradiction remains. And that is, the concept that circumcision marked Jews for certain death contradicts the holocaust narrative that yellow stars were used for marking, and subsequent gassing. Think about it. If the Jewish mark of circumcision was used to mark and kill Jews, yellow stars would not be necessary. If the yellow star was used for checking and killing, looking below the belt would not be needed. The star would take care of that instead.
Which of course raises the question, which version is true according to standard holocaust orthodoxy? They contradict each other.