
So there were 52 muffles, or individual cremation ovens total at Auschwitz?
Moderator: Moderator
I would say that simply scratching your hammer and supposedly finding human bones is tantamount to an easy find.
Maybe the same was the case with the Auschwitz crematoria - your and other Revisionists calculations show that something could not happen - but it did?
"Things are not that simple, Rebbe. Some events do take place but are not true; others are, although they never occurred.
joachim neander wrote:Moderator 3 said:I would say that simply scratching your hammer and supposedly finding human bones is tantamount to an easy find.
I agree.
But please, Mr. Moderator, have a look again into my original post. I wrote about me finding, by chance, the bone fragments at the site of the crematorium of the former concentration camp Ellrich-Juliushütte, a sub-camp of Mittelbau. Ellrich-Juliushütte is about 900 km west from Auschwitz and had never to do anything with Auschwitz.
Mojo wrote:So your Doctorate is in Forensic Anthropology? I assume someone has analyzed these bone frags to make sure that they are not only bone, but human bone?
joachim neander wrote:Mojo wrote:So your Doctorate is in Forensic Anthropology? I assume someone has analyzed these bone frags to make sure that they are not only bone, but human bone?
More questions addressed to me I did not find in your last post.
As an obedient pupil, I'll try to answer them:
1) No, I do not hold a doctor's degree in forensic anthropology. May I humbly ask, if you perhaps do so? You seem so knowledgeable. Chapeau!
2) As I already remarked in one of my posts: if you are at the site of a former crematorium, and there is a mound of ashes, and among them you find a lot of bone fragments - from what else could they have been than from those who were cremated there? If I went to the garbage bin of a KFC and found bones there, I would say these are chicken bones, wouldn't you? Maybe someone has analyzed them, I don't know.
joachim neander wrote: As I already remarked in one of my posts: if you are at the site of a former crematorium, and there is a mound of ashes, and among them you find a lot of bone fragments - from what else could they have been than from those who were cremated there.
joachim neander wrote: If I went to the garbage bin of a KFC and found bones there, I would say these are chicken bones, wouldn't you?
So I'll ask you again: How many cremations occurred in Auschwitz I & II during WWII?
Mojo wrote:1) I'm not the one making claims to have found human bone frags, you are sir. No, I am not an educated man, nor do I claim to be but, I do have plenty of what's known as "walking around sense". I don't need a piece of paper to tell me I am smart. Chapeau!
2) So there's no chance that the bone frags you discovered were from the kitchen and not human after all?
There is no correlation between mounds of ash and cause of death. Finding bones in a war zone shouldn't be considered damaging evidence either. You are making connections without evidence. I feel a "convergence" coming on.
joachim neander wrote:@ Lohengrin:
According to scientific research in aerodynamics, the humble-bee cannot fly. Strangely, it does.
Maybe the same was the case with the Auschwitz crematoria - your and other Revisionists calculations show that something could not happen - but it did?
Neander: According to scientific research in aerodynamics, the humble-bee cannot fly. Strangely, it does. Maybe the same was the case with the Auschwitz crematoria - your and other Revisionists calculations show that something could not happen - but it did?
According to scientific research in aerodynamics, the humble-bee cannot fly. Strangely, it does.
Maybe the same was the case with the Auschwitz crematoria - your and other Revisionists calculations show that something could not happen - but it did?
joachim neander wrote:Yeah, I didn't yet think of it. But maybe you are right with the "war zone" argument. I asked a friend of mine who is living over there. He PMed me that the bones could have been from civilians killed by the Soviets and buried in a mass grave near the crematorium to put the blame on the Germans. He remembers locals having told him that they witnessed something similar. And that, indeed, as far as he knows, never a forensic investigation was made at the place of the ashes. The issue is, I admit, rather complicated.
joachim neander wrote:But let me ask you: what do you think about my friend's point of view?
Return to “'Holocaust' Debate / Controversies / Comments / News”
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests