The topic is Muehlenkamps duplicty in the Sobibor discussion, at least some part of your post should be either about the stated duplicity, or how it impacts the Sobibor discussion.
It looks like Roberto Muehlenkamp's duplicity is being demonstrated again.
My Sobibor Grave # 8 / 46 Proofs
by Pat Swanson
The following information is being presented as proof that alleged - Sobibor grave # 8 / 46 - contains the remains of at least 19 bodies, in accordance with - The National Association of Forensic Historians TM grave numbering system, which can be seen in this webpage here: http://www.vnnforum.com/showpost.php?p= ... count=2629
Roberto Muehlenkamp, VNN post #777:
“…would you please provide the proof of: …Just one ounce of human ash at Sobibor…”
“No problem… IV.2.3 Physical evidence documented in photographs…
A mound of the ashes… at the remembrance site on the grounds of the camp…
A mound of the remains… at the remembrance site on the grounds of the camp…”
Roberto Muehlenkamp, VNN post #902:
…"proving" that the mound of ash at the Sobibor memorial is actually comprised of human ash… will be answered in an article that I shall try to get published in SKEPTIC magazine…”
Roberto Muehlenkamp, VNN post #916:
“…The conclusion that the mound in question is comprised of human ash is thus the conclusion that is borne out by all known evidence and belied by none. It is also the conclusion towards which various sources of evidence independent of each other converge. This convergence of various sources of evidence… is proof that the mound in question is comprised of human ash…”
See the proof that Sobibor’s grave # 8 / 46 contains the remains of at least 19 bodies with your own eyes. (Just as Mr. Shermer did personally when he went to Sobibor to conduct research and to see for himself what evidence there was at the camp.) The following photo “shows a huge mound of ashes and bone fragments surrounded by a stone wall:” http://www.scrapbookpages.com/poland/So ... our01.html
As Roberto Muehlenkamp’s posts point out and the convergence of evidence theory proves, (a theory that Mr. Shermer espouses) Sobibor’s memorial / grave #8 / 46 is comprised of human remains / ash, and it simply defies simple logic, common sense and the convergence of evidence theory that a mound comprised of human remains / ashes as large as the one at Sobibor (see the above photo), does NOT contain the remains of at least 19 bodies.
The preceding information was presented as proof that alleged - Sobibor grave # 8 / 46 - contains the remains of at least 19 bodies in my attempt to lay claim to - The National Association of Forensic Historians TM N.A.F.H. - Crime Scene Investigation Challenge TM - $1,000.00 reward for said grave.
Michael Shermer now has 60 days from today - 6 - 10 -11 - to explicitly and legally certify that he endorses said posted proof. Michael Shermer can explicitly and legally endorse said posted proof by contacting, via email, Greg Gerdes, President of - The National Association of Forensic Historians TM (Contact information can be found at the bottom of their website: http://www.nafcash.com) and making the following statement to Greg Gerdes:
I, Michael Shermer, acting as sole appointed arbiter of - The National Association of Forensic Historians TM - N.A.F.H. - Crime Scene Investigation Challenge TM, do hereby explicitly and legally certify that I categorically endorse the information in - Pat Swanson’s - My Sobibor Grave # 8 / 46 Proofs - thread, as meeting my own, Skeptic Magazine’s and the Skeptics Society’s standards of proof, and that - Sobibor grave # 8 / 46 - does in fact contain the remains of at least 19 bodies. Furthermore, I will publish this certification / endorsement in the next issue of Skeptic Magazine.
(Note: What is to be judged and certified / endorsed by Michael Shermer is all the information that is sandwiched between my opening and closing statements.)
Does anyone know if Roberto Muehlenkamp ever got his Sobibor article published in Skeptic Magazine?