Friedrich Paul Berg wrote:The claim that masses of Jews were gassed in just "three minutes" was made initially in the War Refugee Board Report of mid-1944 by two self-described "eyewitnesses:" Rudolf Vrba and Alfred Wetzler. That famous report was widely distributed in the US at the time and was the basis of many subsequent assertions that the US knew about the mass gassings and should have bombed the tracks to Auschwitz, etc., etc. by people like Wyman, America and the Holocaust.
The entire text of the WRB Report actually appears in: The Bombing of Auschwitz by Michael J. Neufeld and Michael Berenbaum (2000). Berenbaum was and may still be the director of the US Holocaust Memorial Museum. On page 244 we have the folowing: "After three minutes everyone in the chamber is dead."
In Commandant of Auschwitz by Rudolf Hoess [supposedly] (1951) the author actually claims on page 185 that Cyclon B gas was discharged into a group of Russians POWs "killing the victims instantly." On page 198 Hoess supposedly claims in describing another gassing: "The screaming, however, soon changed to the death rattle and in a few minutes all lay still. After twenty minutes at the latest no movement could be sicerned." It seems safe to say that according to Hoess from page 198, the vast majority would have still been dead "in a few minutes."
No doubt, some saner scholars have given more reasonable times for the alleged mass gassings--but, it is they who are tampering with the "evidence" such as it is, and not me. Certainly,Neufeld and Berenbaum qualify in many circles as "holocaust scholars." I suspect that David Irving will try, if he hasn't done so already, to give some revised "goldilocks "number of his own as to how many minutes were actually needed to gas the victims and it will be much longer than three minutes. Of course, Irving will never deny that gassings happened. Shame on him and people like him!
Friedrich Paul Berg
Learn everything at http://www.nazigassings.com
Nazi Gassings Never Happened! Niemand wurde vergast!
I didn't want to offend You, Mr. Berg, but in the debate You portrayed the "3-minute-claim" as for it to be the general narrative of the holohoax-believers, which it isn't.
"as many as 2ooo people were killed with cyanide in just 3 minutes" and "if one believes the hoax that all of the 2000 died within 3 minutes" is what You said, thereby discredting Your own argument from the start.
As for David Irving, did he publish any book on examining the Holocaust?
I'm no radical, and I for sure don't know the final Truth, what I know is that people like ARNO MAYER or FRITJOF MEYER do a lot in contributing to the cause of Holocaust™-Revisionism as well as convinced Deniers, and in the wider picture, Mr. Irving does a hell of a good job by his World War II-/Nazi-Leadership-Portrayal-Revisionism and is thereby indirectly contributing to Holocaust™-Revisionism as well...
Let's agree to disagree on these issues maybe....but all in all I very much appreciate Your efforts in working for the collapse of the Holohoax-Industry!!!
bookmarked http://www.nazigassings.com some time ago.