The most important Photograph / corpse color
Atigun wrote:Last time that I looked, Nessie was over at Skeptic, posting replies to me and other CODOH members. He's claiming that challenging the functionality of the Kula columns is a fallacy of ignorance since nobody has built an actual Kula column and tested it with Zyklon B, under Auschwitz conditions. Well, nobody has ever built and tested a Kula column to see if it would work, either. Uh, Nessie, care to post your replies here on the CODOH forum?
Objection of the following "value": "challenging the functionality of the Perpetuum mobile is a fallacy of ignorance since nobody has built an actual Perpetuum mobile and tested it."
Contrary to Nessie´s another misuse of fallacy, revisionists know from various testimonies, most notably from Kula, how this alleged column device looked like/worked. Based on the description it can be ruled out the functionality or the idea of such device for claimed purpose. Hence it belongs to realm of fantasy unless Nessie cares to finally present his arguments. Last but not least, Nessie is again wrong as revisionists of course built a version of this alleged device, yet is virtually impossible to test it under "Auschwitz conditions" as demonstration for exterminationists who without explanations do not accept backed up objections regarding this alleged device. Hence to make validity of opponent´s arguments dependent on the experiment he knows is impossible to do is "pass the buck" approach to put it mildly and hence irrelevant.
Problem with Nessie´s heavy use of accusation of fallacy is he has little or no knowledge of what is a fallacy and is not able to recognize it like in this case, hence his claimed "fallacies" are virtually only demonstration of his incompetence. As I noted, his new strategy in latest month(s) is misuse of fallacies and to virtually only accusing of "fallacies" to simply discredit opponents and their positions without actually addressing them. Ad hominem is probably overplayed for him, so a new strategy.