New book: "The Six Million: Fact or Fiction?"

Read and post various viewpoints or search our large archives.

Moderator: Moderator

Forum rules
Be sure to read the Rules/guidelines before you post!
User avatar
NLH
Valued contributor
Valued contributor
Posts: 249
Joined: Mon Jul 14, 2014 10:28 pm
Location: England, UK

Re: New book: "The Six Million: Fact or Fiction?"

Postby NLH » 3 years 4 months ago (Thu Apr 09, 2015 9:59 am)

I have this book (the fifth edition, April 2014) and will concur that it is excellent. As I have said, I cannot criticize the contents at all. However, the outer format is a let down: 11" x 8 1/2" is a horrible size, and their is no title down the spine. Other than that the book is a fantastic read. I just really dislike these magazine format spined books. It would be far better as similar in size to that of the Holocaust Handbooks Series books, and on that note, the other letdown is the publisher: CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform. This book is very scholarly and should be published by Barnes/Rudolf. Plus, the horrible format doesn't fit on any shelf. The format it is in now just doesn't do it justice. :wink:

Image


"Believe me, I came into Auschwitz in a much worse condition than I actually left it."
- Kitty Hart-Moxon, Jewish Holocaust Survivor.

June 1998 testimony, USC Shoah Foundation, Visual History Archive.
Part 2 - YouTube - 1:21:42

User avatar
NLH
Valued contributor
Valued contributor
Posts: 249
Joined: Mon Jul 14, 2014 10:28 pm
Location: England, UK

Re: New book: "The Six Million: Fact or Fiction?"

Postby NLH » 2 years 8 months ago (Wed Dec 02, 2015 2:54 pm)

NLH wrote:I have this book (the fifth edition, April 2014) and will concur that it is excellent. As I have said, I cannot criticize the contents at all. However, the outer format is a let down: 11" x 8 1/2" is a horrible size, and their is no title down the spine. Other than that the book is a fantastic read. I just really dislike these magazine format spined books. It would be far better as similar in size to that of the Holocaust Handbooks Series books, and on that note, the other letdown is the publisher: CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform. This book is very scholarly and should be published by Barnes/Rudolf. Plus, the horrible format doesn't fit on any shelf. The format it is in now just doesn't do it justice. :wink:

Image


Apologies, I meant fourth edition above. However, their is a new and updated fifth edition (July 2015) available: http://peterwinterwriting.blogspot.co.u ... ction.html

My criticisms above still apply. In fact, I have just contacted Peter Winter about speaking to Germar Rudolf about publishing it as part of the scholarly Holocaust Handbooks Series, it certainly deserves better than the way it is done now. Will see what he says.

Image
"Believe me, I came into Auschwitz in a much worse condition than I actually left it."
- Kitty Hart-Moxon, Jewish Holocaust Survivor.

June 1998 testimony, USC Shoah Foundation, Visual History Archive.
Part 2 - YouTube - 1:21:42

User avatar
NLH
Valued contributor
Valued contributor
Posts: 249
Joined: Mon Jul 14, 2014 10:28 pm
Location: England, UK

Re: New book: "The Six Million: Fact or Fiction?"

Postby NLH » 2 years 8 months ago (Mon Dec 14, 2015 3:16 pm)

Today I received revisionist Peter Winter's excellent book, The Six Million: Fact or Fiction? in its significantly updated and expanded 5th edition, July 2015 (right). I previously owned the 4th edition, April 2014 (left), and my comments remain the same:

"I cannot criticize the contents at all. However, the outer format is a let down: 11" x 8 1/2" is a horrible size, and their is no title down the spine. Other than that the book is a fantastic read. I just really dislike these magazine format spined books. It would be far better as similar in size to that of the Holocaust Handbooks Series books, and on that note, the other let down is the publisher: CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform. This book is very scholarly and should be published by Barnes/Castle Hill/Rudolf. Plus, the horrible format doesn't fit on any shelf. The format it is in now just doesn't do it justice."


But like I said, I cannot criticise the contents at all.

Image

The back cover states, in part,

"This work is without doubt the single most important revisionist overview of the legend of the “Six Million” Holocaust ever yet published... If you only ever read one book about the Holocaust, this has to be it."


With a blurb like that, which I believe it to stand up to, it evidently deserves a better publisher.

Whilst the contents are significantly updated (details here: http://peterwinterwriting.blogspot.co.u ... ction.html), the new fifth edition features no new edition preface nor updated introduction.

Still, alongside Prof. Dalton's, Debating the Holocaust: A New Look At Both Sides, 2nd edition 2015 (viewtopic.php?f=2&t=9949), they compliment each other exceptionally and are highly recommended.
"Believe me, I came into Auschwitz in a much worse condition than I actually left it."
- Kitty Hart-Moxon, Jewish Holocaust Survivor.

June 1998 testimony, USC Shoah Foundation, Visual History Archive.
Part 2 - YouTube - 1:21:42

User avatar
NLH
Valued contributor
Valued contributor
Posts: 249
Joined: Mon Jul 14, 2014 10:28 pm
Location: England, UK

Re: New book: "The Six Million: Fact or Fiction?"

Postby NLH » 1 year 7 months ago (Wed Dec 28, 2016 11:44 am)

NLH wrote:Today I received revisionist Peter Winter's excellent book, The Six Million: Fact or Fiction? in its significantly updated and expanded 5th edition, July 2015 (right). I previously owned the 4th edition, April 2014 (left), and my comments remain the same:

"I cannot criticize the contents at all. However, the outer format is a let down: 11" x 8 1/2" is a horrible size, and their is no title down the spine. Other than that the book is a fantastic read. I just really dislike these magazine format spined books. It would be far better as similar in size to that of the Holocaust Handbooks Series books, and on that note, the other let down is the publisher: CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform. This book is very scholarly and should be published by Barnes/Castle Hill/Rudolf. Plus, the horrible format doesn't fit on any shelf. The format it is in now just doesn't do it justice."


But like I said, I cannot criticise the contents at all.

Image

The back cover states, in part,

"This work is without doubt the single most important revisionist overview of the legend of the “Six Million” Holocaust ever yet published... If you only ever read one book about the Holocaust, this has to be it."


With a blurb like that, which I believe it to stand up to, it evidently deserves a better publisher.

Whilst the contents are significantly updated (details here: http://peterwinterwriting.blogspot.co.uk/2014/09/the-six-million-fact-or-fiction.html), the new fifth edition features no new edition preface nor updated introduction.

Still, alongside Prof. Dalton's, Debating the Holocaust: A New Look At Both Sides, 2nd edition 2015 (https://forum.codoh.com/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=9949), they compliment each other exceptionally and are highly recommended.


Now in its sixth edition with a number of new sections. Whilst I am waiting for this new edition toof arrive, I am sure my original criticisms remain. However, the new updates look interesting. Read more below.

Now in its sixth edition, The Six Million: Fact or Fiction, has been revised, updated and expanded once again to include a number of new sections.

Image

The new sections include:

- The dismissal of the Wannsee Conference “extermination plan” as a “silly story” by Yad Vashem’s Professor Yehuda Bauer;

- An expansion of the section dealing with the fake “Gas Chamber 1” on display at the Auschwitz Camp;

- A new section exposing the hoax of the “gassing of the Hungarian Jews” and their dispersal to labor camps in Germany;

- Erich von dem Bach-Zelewski’s evidence at the Eichmann trial;

- A new section dealing with the “eye-witness” evidence of Rudolf Reder from Belzec;

- The admission by Anne Frank’s father that he co-authored the book now known as the “Diary of Anne Frank”; and

- An extract from the Korherr Report which reveals that as of December 1942, there were only 9,127 Jews in all the concentration camps.

In addition, the previous appendices dealing with “survivor hoaxes” has been incorporated into the “Eyewitness” chapter.

....................................................................

This work is without doubt the single most important revisionist overview of the legend of the “Six Million” Holocaust ever yet published.

Just some of the amazing revelations in this book include:

- How Zionists and Nazis cooperated before the war on writing Germany’s racial laws—and in the setting up of Jewish settlements in Palestine;

- How Zionists offered to take up arms for Nazi Germany against Britain during World War II;

- How Nazi policy was first aimed at encouraging Jews to emigrate, and then after the war broke out, to evacuating them east of the Urals;

- How official German records shows that there were 4.5 million Jews under Nazi control, and of that number, 4.3 million lodged claims as “Holocaust victims” after the war;

- How the Soviet Union used torture to produce the lion’s share of “confessions” extracted from Germans to support the “extermination” allegations;

- How the Jewish lead prosecutor in the “Einsatzgruppen” trials publicly admitted to having witnessed torture and personally used death threats to extract “confessions”;

- Exactly what Adolf Eichmann Confessed to—and what he did not;

- The shocking lies and distortions contained in the two John Demjanjuk trials;

- How the Auschwitz Camp Museum has formally admitted that the “gas chamber” it has shown to millions of tourists is actually a fake;

- How original German architect plans of Auschwitz show no “gas chambers”;

- How forensic chemical examination of Auschwitz has disproved the use of Zyklon-B in the so-called “ruined gas chambers”;

- How official Israeli and Polish university archaeological digs at Belzec and Sobibór have failed to find any evidence of “gas chambers”; and of how a similar dig at Chelmno directly contradicted “eyewitness” testimony;

- How the “gas chambers” at Majdanek have glass windows, baths, and real showers for the alleged “victims”;

- How the “carbon monoxide” gas bottles on display at Majdanek, still connected to a “gas chamber,” are in fact engraved and marked as “carbon dioxide!”;

- Details of the “Star of David gas chamber tile” hoax at the 2013 Treblinka archaeological dig;

- How a delousing chamber at Dachau has been misrepresented as a homicidal gas chamber;

- How German POWs were forced to alter a shower room at Sachenhausen to support a Soviet show trial—but that the forgery was so crude and embarrassing that the Communists knocked down the building in 1952.

- The Bergen-Belsen camp is also reviewed, along with an explanation of the typhus epidemic which swept the camp in the last months of the war and created the horror images of emaciated dead bodies now associated with “the Holocaust.”

This new version also deals with the “eyewitness survivor” memoirs and their outright lies and forgery, starting with a superbly illustrated expose of the faked memoirs of “Nazi hunter” Simon Wiesenthal and many others.

Finally, the last section discusses the all-important question of how and why the Holocaust storytellers have gone through so much trouble to make up the incredible story of the “Six Million.”

If you only ever read one book about the Holocaust, this has to be it.


180+ illustrations. October 2016 SixthEdition.


TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction

CHAPTER 1: NAZIS AND ZIONISTS BEFORE THE WAR
Section 1: Nazi Anti-Semitism and Jewish Emigration from Greater Germany 1933–1940
Section 2: Zionist and Nazi Collaboration on the 1935 Nuremberg Laws
Section 3: “A Nazi Travels to Palestine”—How the SS Supported the Zionist Colonization of Palestine
Section 4: Nazi Financial Assistance to Zionism: The “Haavara” Transfer Agreement
Section 5: The Jewish Declaration of War against Germany and the Organized Boycott of German Goods
Section 6: The Truth about Kristallnacht
Section 7: The Creation of the Concentration Camps
Section 8: Zionists Offered to Fight for the Nazis against the British

CHAPTER 2: THE NUMBER OF JEWS UNDER NAZI CONTROL
Section 9: There Were 4.5 Million Jews under Direct Nazi Control
Section 10: 4.3 Million Postwar “Holocaust Claims” against German Government
Section 11: Yad Vashem’s “Victim List” Compiled on Hearsay
Section 12: Dieter Wisliceny and Wilhelm Höttl—Spurious Origin of the “Six Million” Number
Section 13: Jewish Holocaust Scholar Raul Hilberg Reduces Total Death Toll to 2.8 Million—but Media Still use the “Six Million” Figure
Section 14: Auschwitz “Death Toll” Officially Reduced by 2.5 Million—but the “Six Million” Figure Remains
Section 15: The Shrinking Number of Dead at Auschwitz: From 9 Million to 73,000
Section 16: The Korherr Report—Only 9,127 Jews in Camps as of December 1942

CHAPTER 3: COMMONLY USED LIES AND DISTORTIONS
Section 17: The Outrageous Lies and Distortions of the “Kurt Gerstein Statement”
Section 18: Jewish Scholars and Yad Vashem Forced to Deny “Soap,” “Lampshades” Horror Stories
Section 19: What was Really Said at the Wannsee Conference in 1942
Section 20: Wannsee “A Silly Story,” says Israel’s Leading Holocaust Scholar
Section 21: What the “Final Solution” Actually Meant: Deportation to the East
Section 22: Hitler’s 1939 “Threat to the Jews” Speech
Section 23: What Hitler Said about the “Extermination” Rumors
Section 24: Himmler’s 1943 Posen Speech and the Meaning of “Ausrotten”
Section 25: Himmler’s Personal Correspondence Never Mentions “Extermination” Claims
Section 26: The Bad Arolsen “International Tracing Service” Archives Provides No Evidence of any Mass Murder Program

CHAPTER 4: THE NUREMBERG WAR CRIMES TRIALS
Section 27: The Legally-Flawed Nuremberg “War Crimes Trials” Did Not “Prove” the Holocaust
Section 28: The Katyn Massacre—How the Soviets Tortured Nazis to “Obtain Confessions”
Section 29: Official “Holocaust” Journal Admits Soviet Torture used to Obtain Nazi “Confessions”

CHAPTER 5: THE EINSATZGRUPPEN—MYTH AND REALITY
Section 30: Anti-Partisan Warfare—The Real Purpose of the Einsatzgruppen (“Task Forces”)
Section 31: Benjamin Ferencz, Jewish Chief Prosecutor at the Einsatzgruppen Trials, Admits to Using Forced Confessions and Death Threats
Section 32: The Einsatzgruppen Ereignismeldungen (“Event Reports”)
Section 33: The Babi Yar Massacre in Kiev: Wartime Aerial Photography Exposes the Lie
Section 34: The “Confession”—and Retraction—of Einsatzgruppen Commander Otto Ohlendorf
Section 35: The Wildly Varying Numbers of Einsatzgruppen “Victims”—1 to 3 million
Section 36: The Oswald Pohl “Confessions”—Example of the Nuremberg Miscarriage of Justice
Section 37: The Perjured Testimony of Erich von dem Bach-Zelewski
Section 38: Bach-Zelewski Repudiates his “Confession”

CHAPTER 6: THE ADOLF EICHMANN TRIAL
Section 39: Eichmann Only Admitted Deporting Jews, Never Murdering Them
Section 40: Eichmann’s Doctored “Memoirs”

CHAPTER 7: THE JOHN DEMJANJUK TRIALS
Section 41: John Demjanjuk—Acquitted in Israel!
Section 42: “Survivor” Testimony Identifies Demjanjuk—But Israeli Supreme Court Dismisses them as Liars
Section 43: German Court Ignores Israeli Decision

CHAPTER 8: THE PSYCHOLOGY OF CONFESSIONS
Section 44: Why Would Anyone “Confess?”
Section 45: The Suchomel “Confession” in Claude Lanzmann’s “Shoah” Movie

CHAPTER 9: “DEATH CAMPS” VERSUS “LABOR CAMPS”
Section 46: Only Six Alleged “Extermination Camps” to “Kill Millions”

CHAPTER 10: AUSCHWITZ
Section 47: Auschwitz Founded as a POW Camp for Polish Soldiers in 1940
Section 48: The Auschwitz I “Gas Chamber”
Section 49: Auschwitz Museum Finally Admits that “Gas Chamber” Was Built After the War
Section 50: Auschwitz II: Architect’s Plans Show No “Gas Chambers”
Section 51: Real Showers in Auschwitz and the “Gas through the Shower-head” Legend
Section 52: Steam Disinfection Stations for Prisoner Clothing as Part of the Anti-Typhus Measures
Section 53: Delousing Chambers Used in All Camps
Section 54: The Auschwitz Clothing Dis-infestation Station Known as the “Central Sauna”
Section 55: The Real Auschwitz Gas Chambers—The “Kanada I” Delousing Chambers
Section 56: Pictures of the Kanada I Zyklon-B Delousing Center in Action
Section 57: Forensic Investigation of “Gas Chamber” Ruins Reveals No Evidence of Gassings
Section 58: Rudolf Report Confirms Forensic Evidence
Section 59: The Auschwitz “Gas Chambers” Change Location
Section 60: The “Gassing of the Hungarian Jews”
Section 61: The Auschwitz Transit Camp
Section 62: Auschwitz’s Real Purpose—A Labor Camp
Section 63: The Rudolf Höss Memoirs
Section 64: Photographs of Auschwitz Inmates Belie Mass Gassing Allegations
Section 65: The Auschwitz Swimming Pool
Section 66: The Frankfurt Auschwitz Trial of 1963

CHAPTER 11: THE AKTION REINHARD CAMPS
Section 67: Details Unknown for Decades
Section 68: The Höfle Telegram
Section 69: Problems with “Gassing by Diesel”
Section 70: The Purpose of the Reinhard Camps

CHAPTER 12: CHELMNO AND “GAS VANS”
Section 71: Chelmno—“Operational” for 18 Months
Section 72: Yad Vashem’s Ostrowski “Gas Van”
Section 73: Walter Rauff and the “Gas Vans”
Section 74: Forensic Digs Contradict “Official History” by Finding “Crematoria” in Chelmno
Section 75: The Chelmno Trials

CHAPTER 13: BELZEC
Section 76: The Belzec Camp—Given Little Prominence Because of Unbelievable Allegations
Section 77: Fantastic Claims from Most Famous “Eyewitness Survivor” Rudolf Reder
Section 78: Belzec’s Incredible Execution Methods: “Electrocution and Drowning in Excrement”
Section 79: The Belzec Trial
Section 80: Forensic Digs at Belzec Contradict “Official” History and Fail to Find “Gas Chambers”

CHAPTER 14: SOBIBÓR
Section 81: Sobibór—A Temporary Camp Which Only Existed for 15 Months
Section 82: Chlorine and Electricity: “Survivors” Claim Bizarre Execution Methods in Sobibór
Section 83: Yitzhak Arad’s Contradictory Official History of Sobibór
Section 84: Official Documents Show Sobibór’s True Function
Section 85: The Sobibór Trials
Section 86: Archaeological Digs Fail To Find Sobibór “Gas Chamber”
Section 87: 2014 Archaeological Dig Contradicts Earlier “Gas Chamber” Claims

CHAPTER 15: TREBLINKA
Section 88: Treblinka—Another Temporary Camp Which Only Existed for 15 Months
Section 89: Treblinka I and II—Labor and Transit Area
Section 90: The Famous “Black Book of Polish Jewry” Claims Execution by “Steam” in Treblinka
Section 91: US National Archive Aerial Photography of Treblinka Shows No Sign of “Extermination Camp
Section 92: “Survivors” Claim Execution by “Vacuum Chambers”
Section 93: First 1999 Forensic Examination of Treblinka Site Reveals No Mass Graves
Section 94: The 2010 Second Forensic Analysis of Treblinka Reveals No “Mass Graves”
Section 95: The 2013 Third Forensic Analysis of Treblinka and the “Star of David Gas Chamber Tiles” Hoax
Section 96: The “Evidence” of “Treblinka Guard” Paval Leleko
Section 97: The Franz Stangl Trial and His “Memoirs”

CHAPTER 16: MAJDANEK
Section 98: Majdanek, Lublin—Originally Built as POW Camp for Soviet Army Prisoners
Section 99: First Majdanek Show Trial, 1944
Section 100: Number of Madjanek “Victims” Varies Wildly from 1.7 Million to 79,000
Section 101: “Gas Chamber” Added to Postwar Rebuilt Madjanek Crematorium Building
Section 102: The Impossibility of the Majdanek “Gas Chambers”
Section 103: Majdanek’s Real Showers for “Gassing Victims”
Section 104: Majdanek’s “Gas Bottles” on Display are Carbon Dioxide, Not Carbon Monoxide
Section 105: The Anomalies of Majdanek’s Second and Third “Gas Chambers”
Section 106: The Plain Glass Window in Majdanek’s Fourth “Gas Chamber”
Section 107: The “Harvest Festival” Hoax
Section 108: The Mußfeldt “Confession”
Section 109: The Second Majdanek Trial of 1975

CHAPTER 17: DACHAU
Section 110: Dachau and Its Mysterious “Gas Chamber”
Section 111: The Real Dachau Gas Chambers— Delousing Cubicles
Section 112: Dachau Casualty Figures Officially “Reduced” from 238,000 to 20,000

CHAPTER 18: SACHSENHAUSEN
Section 113: Sachsenhausen: Gas Chamber Built in November 1945, Knocked Down in 1952

CHAPTER 19: BERGEN-BELSEN
Section 114: Typhus Deaths—Origin of Horror Images in Bergen-Belsen—No Gas Chambers

CHAPTER 20: “EYEWITNESS” ACCOUNTS
Section 115: Simon Wiesenthal’s Faked “Memoirs”
Section 116: The Diary of Anne Frank—Handwriting Reveals Two Authors
Section 117: Anne Frank Fund Admits Father Co-Authored Diary
Section 118: Rudolf Vrba’s “I Cannot Forgive”
Section 119: Olga Lengyel’s “Five Chimneys”
Section 120: Kitty Hart’s “Return to Auschwitz”
Section 121: Martin Gray’s “For Those I Loved”
Section 122: Jean Francis Steiner’s “Treblinka”
Section 123: Miklos Nyiszli’s “Auschwitz: A Doctor’s Eyewitness Account”
Section 124: Filip Müller’s “Eyewitness Auschwitz: Three Years in the Gas Chambers”
Section 125: Truthful Survivor Books Not Given Prominence
Section 126: Paul Rassinier—The Holocaust Victim Who Argued Against the “Gas Chambers”
Section 127: Martin Gilbert’s “Auschwitz and the Allies”
Section 128: Klara Markus, and the Psychology behind “Holocaust Survivor Testimonies”
Section 129: Herman Rosenblat’s “Angel at the Fence”
Section 130: Binjamin Wilkomirski’s “Fragments”
Section 131: “Survivor” Swindlers 1—The Philip Auerbach Case
Section 132: “Survivor” Swindlers 2—The Werner Nachmann Case
Section 133: “Survivor” Swindlers 3—The Semen Domnitser Case

CHAPTER 21: OUTLANDISH HOLOCAUST CLAIMS
Section 134: Bears and Eagles in Cages Eating Jews; Jewish “Soap Burial” in Atlanta, USA; Sausages Made out of Jews; Mummified Thumbs as Light Switches; “Pedal-driven Brain-bashing Machines”—And More, All in Nuremberg Court as “Evidence.”

CHAPTER 22: CONCLUSION
Section 135: The “Holocaust”—What Actually Happened
Section 136: Why Was the Holocaust Story Invented?
Appendix 1: Alois Brunner and the “I Would Do It All Again” Lie
Appendix 2: The Oskar Groening “I Saw the Gas Chambers” Story
Appendix 3: Auschwitz—Reality versus the Claims
Index

http://peterwinterwriting.blogspot.co.uk/2016/11/the-six-million-fact-or-fiction-sixth.html
Attachments
1482291408922.jpg
1482291408922.jpg (376.81 KiB) Viewed 1562 times
52ew7c.jpg
52ew7c.jpg (67.7 KiB) Viewed 1562 times
"Believe me, I came into Auschwitz in a much worse condition than I actually left it."
- Kitty Hart-Moxon, Jewish Holocaust Survivor.

June 1998 testimony, USC Shoah Foundation, Visual History Archive.
Part 2 - YouTube - 1:21:42

avatar
AntiBeliever
Member
Member
Posts: 30
Joined: Mon Jul 11, 2016 3:29 pm

Re: New book: "The Six Million: Fact or Fiction?"

Postby AntiBeliever » 1 year 7 months ago (Sat Dec 31, 2016 10:36 pm)

As much as I do believe this book seems like a great introductory read, a few things came to mind:
-It's probably not a good idea to dedicate your last section to why the Holocaust myth was created. It just makes it seem like every single Jewish survivor was lying for war reparations, which would give the reader the impression that the author is politically motivated.
-For the amount of sections there are, it doesn't have enough pages. At the very least, 2 pages would suffice for 1 section and still give the reader a comfortable amount. I just can't see how you can sum up that many sections in less than 2 pages.

Other than that, it's great, and covers all the bases. :)

User avatar
Hannover
Valuable asset
Valuable asset
Posts: 9490
Joined: Sun Nov 24, 2002 7:53 pm

Re: New book: "The Six Million: Fact or Fiction?"

Postby Hannover » 1 year 7 months ago (Sat Dec 31, 2016 11:12 pm)

AntiBeliever wrote:As much as I do believe this book seems like a great introductory read, a few things came to mind:
-It's probably not a good idea to dedicate your last section to why the Holocaust myth was created. It just makes it seem like every single Jewish survivor was lying for war reparations, which would give the reader the impression that the author is politically motivated.
-For the amount of sections there are, it doesn't have enough pages. At the very least, 2 pages would suffice for 1 section and still give the reader a comfortable amount. I just can't see how you can sum up that many sections in less than 2 pages.

Other than that, it's great, and covers all the bases. :)

So then, they weren't / aren't lying for war reparations when they claim what is impossible, or when they contradict each other every way possible?

Have they refused to make reparations claims? Nope.
Do they refuse the money they have demanded? Not a penny.

They are very well paid when they lie to impressionable school children, or to magazines, newspapers which print their ridiculous tales.
How about the big time cash they get when there are propaganda movies made about them?
How about the bizarre books? $$$

Yes they are liars. What else do you call those who accuse an entire ethnic group of crimes that did not, could not occur?

Give me a break, since when aren't lying Zionists "politically motivated"? That's hilarious.

So Israel isn't politically motivated when they commemorate the '6M' which were never killed?
When they demand billions from Germany?
When they demand billions every year from US taxpayers?
When they demand that Europe and the US accept massive immigration while they ban anyone who isn't a Jew from entering "that shitty little country".

How about when they demand laws against free speech, scrutiny & debate about the impossible 'holocau$t' storyline?
That's as "politically motivated" as anything can possibly be.

- Hannover

"Alone the fact that one may not question the Jewish "holocaust" and that Jewish pressure has inflicted laws on democratic societies to prevent questions—while incessant promotion and indoctrination of the same averredly incontestable ‘holocaust’ occur—gives the game away. It proves that it must be a lie. Why else would one not be allowed to question it? Because it might offend the "survivors"? Because it "dishonors the dead"? Hardly sufficient reason to outlaw discussion. No, because the exposure of this leading lie might precipitate questions about so many other lies and cause the whole ramshackle fabrication to crumble."

- Gerard Menuhin / righteous Revisionist Jew, son of famous violinist
If it can't happen as alleged, then it didn't.

avatar
AntiBeliever
Member
Member
Posts: 30
Joined: Mon Jul 11, 2016 3:29 pm

Re: New book: "The Six Million: Fact or Fiction?"

Postby AntiBeliever » 1 year 7 months ago (Sun Jan 01, 2017 10:35 am)

Am I denying these things are happening? Not at all, but what you've just said about the survivors is incredibly silly. Not every single survivor was inside one of the alleged extermination camps. For those that were in camps like Belsen, they wouldn't be able to tell who caused the typhus epidemics and starvation - they can only assume it was the people holding them as prisoners. That's not a deliberate lie for gain, not to mention anybody who got sick would rightfully be open to claim that money.

Yes, there is a conspiracy to swindle and con people out of their money and piece of mind, and I wish more would know about revisionist work. Censorship is a terrible thing, but that's why we have revisionists in English countries like Germar, Bud, Eric Hunt, Butz, and others. Now let's assume that lots more people were open to revisionist work - what impression would they get if they were to come across this thread and certain other things you've posted?

User avatar
Hannover
Valuable asset
Valuable asset
Posts: 9490
Joined: Sun Nov 24, 2002 7:53 pm

Re: New book: "The Six Million: Fact or Fiction?"

Postby Hannover » 1 year 7 months ago (Sun Jan 01, 2017 10:51 am)

AntiBeliever wrote:Am I denying these things are happening? Not at all, but what you've just said about the survivors is incredibly silly. 1. Not every single survivor was inside one of the alleged extermination camps. 2 For those that were in camps like Belsen, they wouldn't be able to tell who caused the typhus epidemics and starvation - they can only assume it was the people holding them as prisoners. 3.That's not a deliberate lie for gain, not to mention anybody who got sick would rightfully be open to claim that money.

4.Yes, there is a conspiracy to swindle and con people out of their money and piece of mind, and I wish more would know about revisionist work. Censorship is a terrible thing, but that's why we have revisionists in English countries like Germar, Bud, Eric Hunt, Butz, and others. Now let's assume that lots more people were open to revisionist work - what impression would they get if they were to come across this thread and certain other things you've posted?

1. Yet they claim to be "survivors".

2. Nonsensical. Diseases can't be used as a tool for murder since those same diseases would also impact those who supposedly "caused" & spread the diseases. Bizarre thinking, AB.

3. Therefore it is a deliberate lie. Did they apply for so called "reparations" or not? Yes they did. Did they they take the money or not? Yes, every penny and they want more & more, & more. See my previous post for more. It's called "The Holocaust Industry" for valid reasons.

4. Predictably you fail to give examples. The impression that logical, unbiased, & rational readers will get is that they have been ripped off by phony "survivors" and a hate mongering Industry which has conjured up and lied about a narrative that is utterly impossible.

- Hannover

If the alleged ‘holocaust’ was fact, then why are there laws in Europe to prevent scrutiny of it? What kind of “truth” needs to imprison people to prevent free speech?
If it can't happen as alleged, then it didn't.

avatar
georgesmiley
Member
Member
Posts: 43
Joined: Thu Apr 11, 2013 1:44 pm

Re: New book: "The Six Million: Fact or Fiction?"

Postby georgesmiley » 6 months 6 days ago (Thu Feb 08, 2018 10:02 am)

Amazon shoahed this book and Mr winter has kindly released it for free (7th edition)

PDF here https://ia801501.us.archive.org/9/items ... %207ed.pdf

Thank you Mr Winter.

avatar
slob
Member
Member
Posts: 33
Joined: Thu Jan 18, 2018 3:06 pm

Re: New book: "The Six Million: Fact or Fiction?"

Postby slob » 6 months 5 days ago (Fri Feb 09, 2018 8:19 am)

georgesmiley wrote:Amazon shoahed this book and Mr winter has kindly released it for free (7th edition)

PDF here https://ia801501.us.archive.org/9/items ... %207ed.pdf

Thank you Mr Winter.


Thanks for the link.

User avatar
Hektor
Valuable asset
Valuable asset
Posts: 3139
Joined: Sun Jun 25, 2006 7:59 am

Re: New book: "The Six Million: Fact or Fiction?"

Postby Hektor » 1 week 1 day ago (Wed Aug 08, 2018 12:47 pm)

AntiBeliever wrote:Am I denying these things are happening? Not at all, but what you've just said about the survivors is incredibly silly. Not every single survivor was inside one of the alleged extermination camps. For those that were in camps like Belsen, they wouldn't be able to tell who caused the typhus epidemics and starvation - they can only assume it was the people holding them as prisoners. That's not a deliberate lie for gain, not to mention anybody who got sick would rightfully be open to claim that money. ....

We are not saying they are all lying!
Some may just be in error about some things.

Fact is also that some previous internees realized that it wasn't the Germans that were to blame for the shortages or that they were deliberately withholding food.


Return to “'Holocaust' Debate / Controversies / Comments / News”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 15 guests