Good Job...If your intention was to create a mess!
Looks like you wanted to summerize all CODOH in one single thread, hoping to keep a openend and clear discussion.
It is like asking "do you like or hate the USA?" or "Here is why i think Jesus never existed?" or "Why i believe in God!"
What you did is putting the most wellknown Revisionist's arguments (the good and the bad ones) in one block! and asked "What do you think?"
What were your expectations? really
Carolyn said
this is why I don't believe in the "quiet reasonableness" promoted by Kingfisher
On the contrary...i would said that is why your ideological and political inspired postings won't never be accepted except by your fans!
If you would want to "convert" anyone, even only have a serious discussions on this subject, I would suppose it like schooling...it's a long process...step by step...teached by qualified persons...( I mean a person that have sufficiant knowledge of each of the points you refered to.
You don't learn a kid to read by giving him the bible to read for next week!
You started by stating that All the alledged Nazis crimes were invented to distract the people from the crimes committed by the Allies and the Russians! Of course, no need to prove or support all those Allies' crimes, they are "WELL-KNOWN", but of course, the Germans never committed any crimes as they were no proven gaz chambers at Brikenau... Well to settle the atmosphere of a further debate, it is a bit strong don't you think?
Then follows
the IMT of Nuremberg was only after intense lobbying of the "world Jewish congress"!
- First this is nonsense...Morgenthau, wich could be described as a jewish influence, never supported the trials and would have love to have all the Nazis shot...But maybe Stalin was Jewish, as well as de Gaulle and Jackson...? As it is well known that the first GRAND trial was all about the suffering of the Jews...
- Second from the start - because we are not even at the end of the begining of the subject of your debate- it's indeed raised the question of your knowledge of the IMT- as you don't give any sources to support this assertion.
- Third, who ,among your leftist forumers has a real knowledge of those trials?
There can't be a real debate in those conditions...only exchanges of baseless opinions...
As i see it, it would have quickly degenerated in a debate about the Jews, their politics, their powers, their conspiracies, etc...and Anti-Semitism in the end...A mess as i said!
I mean you could have started by proposing "Let's all read Stäglish and let's discuss the book next week"! or only adressed your opinion on the IMT (with sources)...The same way you could have provided a link so that every could at this great movie that is "Der Ewige Jude" before discussing it.
What you tried to do is to kidnap a monk to trying convince him that is life has been a waste and that God do not exist"
So again, what did you expect?